Blog Layout

In praise of the Incomplete Leader

“Be a good leader. Be incomplete. Don't be perfect, don't even try............”


There is evidence that the best leaders are distinctly far from perfect and simply incomplete.


When I look at my personal skills, this is the best news I've heard in some time!


An older article in the July 2007 volume of the Harvard Business Review caught my attention recently. In Praise of the Incomplete Leader is the collaborative work of a group of authors that includes Peter Senge (the Learning Organisation) and Deborah Ancona. The article resonated with me from the first read of the summary tag line:

“No leader is perfect. The best ones don’t try to be—they concentrate on honing their strengths and find others who can make up for their limitations”. 


The authors state that it is time to stop visualizing the complete leader as a person at the top who has all the answers. They go on to say that leaders shouldn't even try to fill the gap. As they say,

“….the sooner leaders stop trying to be all things to all people, the better off their organizations will be. In today’s world, the executive’s job is no longer to command and control but to cultivate and coordinate the actions of others at all levels of the organization. Only when leaders come to see themselves as incomplete—as having both strengths and weaknesses—will they be able to make up for their missing skills by relying on others”. 


A quick summary of the author's findings suggests that a leader should focus on four essential capabilities:

  • Sensemaking: Trying to understand the contexts in which in which an organization and its people operate. Sensemaking is similar to creating a roadmap that the team can follow.
  • Relating: Building relationships within and across the organisation. Building a community of confidants who can collaborate to solve problems.
  • Visioning: Creating a compelling picture of the future. A leader should be able to articulate what the team wants to create.
  • Inventing: Developing new ways to achieve the vision. Similar to the innovation skills required of entrepreneurs, this is more about execution than creativity.



Furthermore, leaders should diagnose their strengths in each of these capabilities and seek help from others if they believe they are deficient. Some clues about your potential deficiencies can be summarized as follows: 

Capability  Look for help in this capability if you…. 
Sensemaking Feel strongly that you’re always right
Feel resentful when things change
Relating Feel that you are constantly being let down by others – they can’t be trusted
Frequently experience unpleasant, argumentative interactions with others
Visioning Often wonder “why are we doing this?”
Can’t remember the last time you felt excited about your work
Inventing Have difficultly relating the organisation’s vision to what you’re doing today
Find that things tend to revert to business as usual

So, give up trying to be perfect. Recognise your incompleteness and seek contributions from others. You’ll be a better leader for it.

 

Based on some ideas from David Rock, Deborah Ancona and Peter Senge


Subscribe to our regular articles, insights and thought leadership

By Norman Chorn March 27, 2023
In my previous article "Accelerate Performance with Strategic Alignment - Define the logic of your strategy", we demonstrated the alignment between the market and business strategy by matching the logic of the market with the logic of the strategy. The Explore logic emphasises a market where customers seek new solutions for emerging requirements. The strategy responds by exploring new opportunities and driving for growth. The Exploit logic occurs in a more stable market where customers seek lower costs and reliability of supply. The appropriate strategy focuses on operational efficiency and building close customer relationships. Culture is key to shaping the capabilities of the business to successfully implement strategy . It drives the way that people behave, decisions are made and actions are taken. It determines, therefore, the strategy that is actually realised in the market, as opposed to that which is merely intended. We make a key distinction between the desired culture and the appropriate culture. The desired culture is what people may choose because it sounds attractive and in vogue. However, the appropriate culture is the culture that is required to successfully implement the chosen strategy. Often, these can be different. For example, people might seek to develop a culture that is ‘innovative’, ‘flexible’ and ‘empowering’, but this may not be the appropriate culture needed to successfully implement the business strategy. DEVELOP THE APPROPRIATE CULTURE FOR YOUR STRATEGY Developing the appropriate culture requires a deliberate emphasis on certain cultural attributes and making trade-offs on others. As we will see, the attributes that are traded off are usually the opposites of those that are emphasised.
2 puzzle pieces
By Norman Chorn March 27, 2023
In Part 1 "How to Accelerate Performance with Strategic Alignment - Understand the Logic of the Market" we outlined different market conditions and defined them in terms of two overarching logics — Exploring and Exploiting . To briefly recap, an Exploring logic is one where customers are seeking new solutions for emerging needs. It’s all about change and action. An Exploiting logic occurs in a more stable market in which the issues are about lowering costs and working collaboratively with customers. It’s a market that focuses on stability and cohesion. FORCES THAT SHAPE YOUR STRATEGY Clearly, it is one of these two logics — or a combination of both — that will shape your strategy as you operate in these markets. See figure 1 below that describes how these logics will form your business strategy:
Share by: